Secret Santa Gift Ideas for Her

Christmas is right around the corner, which means the season of gift-giving is upon us. At Perfectly Priscilla, this is one of our favorite parts about the holidays because there’s nothing better than showing our loved ones how we feel and giving them the perfect christmas gifts. If you’ve got a Secret Santa exchange on the calendar this season, you might be wondering what exactly to get your giftee. That’s why we’ve compiled this list of Secret Santa gift ideas for her.

Secret Santa presents don’t need to be over-the-top or extravagant to make someone feel special. Just keep her personal style, habits, and hobbies in mind, and you’ll be able to come up with lots of little somethings to offer her. Still feeling stuck? No worries! These eight Secret Santa gift ideas for her will help you get the ball rolling with your super-secret shopping list.

8 Secret Santa Gifts for Her

A Secret Santa gift exchange is meant to be fun with friends or family. The right presents will make your person feel special and get her into the holiday spirit. However, it might be tough to think of the perfect thing to give, especially if you don’t know this woman very well. These eight thoughtful Secret Santa gift ideas for her will inspire you to find just the thing whether you’re on a budget or ready to splurge.

1. Trendy Scarf

There’s nothing better than a cozy, festive scarf during the Christmas season. That’s why a trendy and stylish scarf makes an excellent Secret Santa Gift for her. Scarves are a winter wardrobe essential that virtually anyone can get use out of during the holidays. When you shop for a scarf for a Secret Santa present, think soft, warm, and cheery. At Perfectly Priscilla, we adore plaid scarves for the holidays. Check out our Gets Me Going Plaid Scarf and What I Like Blanket Scarf. If you know she loves animal-print accessories, the No Other Way Cheetah-Print Scarf is another great option. A beautifully patterned scarf is an ideal Secret Santa gift because it’s both functional and seasonal. Scarves can be worn indoors or outdoors, day or night, for casual and fancy events this Christmas.

2. Festive Earrings

Does your giftee love wearing eye-catching earrings? A pair of festive earrings might be an ideal Secret Santa gift for her. You can pick up a set she’ll love to wear this season without spending a fortune. Some of our budget-friendly favorites from Perfectly Priscilla’s holiday accessory line include the sparkly beaded Great Choice Earrings, the gold tasseled What Comes Next Earrings, the glittery silver I Got This Earrings, the totally unique Control Yourself Earrings, and the trendy gold Perfect Set Earrings. Whether she’s got a fancy dinner, casual shopping day, or glamorous New Year’s Eve party to attend, some eye-catching earrings might be just the thing she needs to complete her outfit.

3. Sassy Tumbler

Just about anyone on your Christmas shopping list can use a tumbler to keep their hot or cold drinks in. That’s why a sassy tumbler is one of the best Secret Santa gift ideas for her. For on-the-go chilled beverages, check out Perfectly Priscilla’s clear PPB Acrylic Tumblr. It has a secure screw-on lid, durable straw, and double walls to keep cold drinks cold for hours without creating any condensation. The Perfectly Priscilla logo and cheeky graphic detail make this a perfect gift for any PPB enthusiast. If she’s an avid coffee or tea drinker, you might consider the PPB Stainless Steel Tumbler. It’s sturdier and more sustainable than standard hot-drink cups and is designed to keep drinks warm for hours on end. The spill-proof suction lid and durable stainless steel design make this quality tumbler ideal for almost anyone on your shopping list. A sassy tumbler is an ideal Secret Santa present for busy women.

4. Cheery Necklace

A cheery necklace is always a great Secret Santa gift idea for fancy ladies who like to add a bit of pizazz to their outfits. Also, you can find tons of fun options for under $25 if your on a budget this Christmas. We love the circle pendant Breaking The Rule Necklace, the red and gold Good Luck Charm Necklace, the ornate tasseled Give Me A Hint Necklace, and the delicate, beaded Don’t Wait On It Necklace from our holiday jewelry line. The necklaces from Perfectly Priscilla are fancy yet versatile and can be paired with any plus-size Christmas outfit idea you have in mind.

5. Winter Hat

When it comes to foolproof Secret Santa gift ideas for her, a winter hat is at the top of the list, especially if you live somewhere with chilly temperatures. At Perfectly Priscilla, we are big fans of gifting knit beanies for Christmas. If you’re not sure what to get for your Secret Santa gift exchange, consider our black Head Strong Pom Beanie. This cute and totally on-trend acrylic winter hat can be worn endlessly through the holidays and the rest of the cold season. It was made with a cozy textured knit pattern and an adorable faux fur pom on the top. The extra warm material is both fashionable and functional, making this cold-weather accessory a stellar Secret Santa gift for her.

6. Graphic Tee

When you think of Secret Santa gift ideas for her, you might not consider clothing at first. However, a festive graphic tee can be a great present that won’t break the bank. At Perfectly Priscilla, we carry many plus-size graphic tees in comfortable fits including several that will get her in the Christmas Spirit. Is your giftee a curvy woman with casual style? A graphic tee could be the perfect Secret Santa present for her. Check out our fun Deer In The Headlights Tee. It comes in either black or a rich, wine shade with a flattering, casual cut and a sexy cutout bustline. The soft material is just the right amount of stretchy and the white deer graphic print is perfect for the holiday season. It can be worn with jeans, leggings, or even a skirt. If you’re gifting to a whiskey drinker, you might also consider the Smooth As Tennessee Whiskey Top. The pinky rust color and charming tie detail will look great on any spunky, sassy plus-size woman.

7. Wear-Anywhere Bracelet

For more Secret Santa gifts for her in the jewelry category, another cool idea is a wear-anywhere bracelet. Bracelets are simple, girly, and can be worn with any ensemble during the Christmas season and beyond. And – bonus! – you can find them for extremely reasonable prices. Perfectly Priscilla’s beaded white, gray, or mauve On Again Off Again Bracelet and our The One You Want Bracelet Set are a couple of our favs. Stackable bracelets are super on-trend for accessories this holiday season. They can add the perfect amount of sparkle and shine to both laid-back and formal ensembles.

8. Knit Sweater

With a little higher Secret Santa spending limit, you might opt for a knit sweater. This is a winter wardrobe essential that everyone can use during the holiday season. Check out our cozy Great Timing Top in heather gray. The material is exceptionally soft and warm making it the perfect thing to wear during the chilly season. We adore the three-quarter-length sleeves and modest neckline. You might also go for the All My Life Plaid Top if you’re shopping for someone whose style is preppy and classic. The timeless plaid pattern is both neutral and seasonal, and the tie-waist detail makes it extra flattering for a plus-size figure.

Other Secret Santa Gift Ideas for Her

If jewelry, clothing, tumblers, or cold-weather accessories don’t seem quite right for the woman you’re shopping for, there are plenty other routes you can take when it comes to the perfect Secret Santa gifts for her.


Are you shopping for a bookworm who’s always got her hands on a new read? You might want to give her a new best-seller or a gift card to buy a digital book, depending on how she likes to read.

Lotions & Soaps

If she’s the type who always keeps yummy-smelling lotion at her desk or in her purse, consider getting her an assortment of lotions and soaps. You can find tons of fun seasonal options this time of year!

Holiday Candle

Speaking of holiday scents, one of the best Secret Santa gift ideas for her is a candle. What woman doesn’t like burning candles this time of year, especially when they smell like gingerbread or pine trees?

Toiletry Bag

Is your giftee a frequent traveler or always heading to or from the gym? A toiletry bag is a great gift for on-the-go jet-setters or ladies who need to access the essentials to freshen up throughout the day.

Warm Socks

Socks are one of the most common Secret Santa gifts for her, and for good reason! Everyone can use new socks, and warm and cozy options are oh-so-welcome this time of year.

Seasonal Sweets

‘Tis the season for yummy sweets and treats. Does this woman love peppermint bark, candy canes, or gingerbread cookies? Think about getting her some seasonal sweets.

Coffee Shop Gift Card

If you’re shopping for a gal who never leaves the house without stopping for a latte, a coffee shop gift card makes an excellent Secret Santa present. You might even consider pairing a gift card with the PPB Stainless Steel Tumbler for a complete gift package.

Fancy Tea

Avid tea drinkers can never get enough tea options! Consider buying a box or two of some fancy tea. There are lots of yummy holiday flavors to choose from this time of year.

Picture Frame

For sentimental gals who keep photos of their family in their wallet and at their desk, a picture frame is always a fabulous Secret Santa gift idea. Unless you’re familiar with her specific taste or home decor, opt for a simple frame.


Are you shopping for someone who loves to workout with music or listen to podcasts during the day? Earbuds make a fantastic gift and come in virtually any color and style.

Wine Stopper

Is this a lady who loves her wine? Why not get her a fun wine stopper for Christmas? You can find tons of holiday-themed stoppers as well as classic designs. If your budget is a little higher, include a bottle of vino as well!


Stationary and thank-you cards are something almost every woman can use this time of year. Consider gifting her a cute set of thank-you cards to send to all the people who show her love this season.

Calendar or Day Planner

If you’re gift shopping for a type-A lady who’s always jotting things down, a calendar or day planner might be the perfect present. Plus, the new year is right around the corner, and she might be ready to start planning for January!

Nail Polish

Nail polish is a fun, easy option for ladies obsessed with keeping their nails fresh. You’ll probably know if your giftee is a frequent nail-painter. If so, pick up two or three bottles of some Christmas colors, like sparkly red or deep forest green.

Preparing for the holidays can be overwhelming, especially when it comes to finding the perfect gift for each and every person on your shopping list. Secret Santa gift exchanges always seem like a good idea in theory, but they can leave you feeling panicked if you’re not quite sure what you get for the person whose name you drew.

At Perfectly Priscilla, we completely understand the feeling of being stumped about what to buy for Christmas presents. Whether you decide on a scarf, earrings, tumbler, necklace, hat, graphic tee, or bracelet, we’re confident that one of these easy Secret Santa gift ideas for her will be just the thing. By picking up an awesome gift for her from Perfectly Priscilla, you can save yourself the stress of Secret Santa shopping.

XYour Shopping Bag